Thoughts On The Loss of Community in America

Will Hinton's picture

My friend Jeff Shinabarger wrote a very thought provoking post earlier this week about community in the wake of tornadoes that came through his neighborhood in East Atlanta. His post ended up being a great topic of discussion with my posse this week and prompted these thoughts from me:

I've been thinking about this idea of community for years and I can't quite put my finger on what has caused a general decline in the sense of community. Many people talk about the rise of suburbs or wealth as primary reasons but I think that those are but small contributing factors. Many of my friends grew up in suburban neighborhoods in Atlanta or elsewhere and had a tremendous sense of community. I know that I did in my prototypical suburban neighborhood. In my cul-de-sac infested suburban sprawl neighborhood, I have at one point been inside every single house in that neighborhood and dozens in surrounding neighborhoods. And not just those where my friends lived. There was a sense as a kid that I could get in almost as much trouble with another adult in the neighborhood as with my parents; parents weren't afraid to actually discipline other people's kids even if they hardly knew them. I have talked about these experiences with friends who grew up in other parts of the country, with friends who grew up in poverty stricken neighborhoods, and those who grew up around the country club and while the details may differ, the general experience of community was the same.

The two things that I have been able to point to as being primary contributors to the loss of community have been technology and the worship of individualism. I am as much of a proponent of technology as anyone, but I think in many ways it has had a corrosive effect on our society and community. While my generation was the first to play video games, my childhood memories are still primarily filled with thoughts of playing baseball or football in the neighborhood with friends. When is the last time that any of you saw a group of kids playing baseball or football in someone's yard in the neighborhood that appeared to be simply an impromptu normal activity? And this isn't just a childhood issue; these days little is thought of adults spending their free time playing video games or watching television in their secluded home theater. It is all these little things that start to steal what little community remains. No doubt that technology has done great things for people including myself. But in typical American fashion, we have gorged ourselves on technology without considering the impact on our community and culture.

Probably the biggest killer of community is our worship of individualism. And I think we (me) are all guilty of it. After all, who has the right to tell me how to raise my kids, live my life? It is nobody's business what I do with my property, my time, my resources. On the surface and in moderation, these ideas aren't all bad. But many Americans have elevated these to primary concerns. Ask yourself, what would your reaction be if a total stranger in a restaurant disciplined your child who was running around? And then think what your parent's or your grandparent's reaction would have been.

Interestingly, this is an area where Christians can positively impact our culture. Shouldn't we be giving ourselves away to our neighbors and our community? What would it look like if once a week or once a month we decided to do someone's yardwork for them or ring the doorbell and ask if we can get our neighbors anything from the grocery story? The crazy thing is that these "not-uncommon-things-years-ago" appear a bit weird and freaky, even counter-cultural these days. Well, isn't that what Christians are called to do and be?

Posted In

Given that you and I would

Given that you and I would not even be acquainted apart from technology, I'm not sure why it's such a bad thing. Where technology has impacted society along the lines of what you suggest, in my opinion, is in the mobility it affords us, thus breaking up extended family and making it easier to relocate for economic reasons and making friendships more tenuous.

I also disagree about individualism being at the heart of it as well. God made us free, and community insists that I give some measure of that liberty up in order to exist in it. That remains, nonetheless, a free choice, a sacrifice. When you bring matters to individual rights in the manner you discuss above, by whose right do we take these away from anyone else apart from their transgression against another? Any "ism" will inevitably devolve into an idol left unchecked, but I think the reason people have elevated individual rights to the level they have is the perception that these rights are under threat.

Rev. Mike (not verified) | June 9, 2008 - 8:53pm

The diminishing sense of

The diminishing sense of community is a trend I've been observing and reflecting on for years. As life becomes more convenient, we realize less and less the extent to which we depend on others. We have such an efficient supply chain that we forget all the farmers, drivers, clerks, cooks, etc., involved in getting us our food, for example. When we don't interact with these people and don't realize our dependency on them, we tend to care less about them. It's neither sudden nor intentional; we've gotten into such a habit of convenience that this habit has hardened into our character.

Maybe this is what people aspire to be. Do we all desire to be 100% independent and autonomous? Why ask your neighbor for a cup of sugar when you can drive to the 24hr grocery store in your SUV (and while you're there use your debit card so you don't even need to be bothered by talking to the checker)? Another example: how many people yell profanity at the guy who calls their house to do a survey, and would those same people ever talk like that to somebody face-to-face? Maybe this convenient culture we're all addicted to is letting us be the selfish jerks we always desired to be, but the technology just wasn't there until recently.

I'm kinda playing the devil's advocate here. There are tons of kind hearted people out there who don't act like selfish jerks. However, it seems like the masses are content to take whatever they can get, do whatever they want, and not consider the implications. I hope that the Christians (and Jews and Muslims and Buddhists) who truly care about things outside themselves will set a good example for the masses.

Ray Moro (not verified) | July 30, 2008 - 3:15pm

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Images can be added to this post.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.